I have been hemming and hawing over a Belinda Stronach blog for a while now. On the one hand, as a Canadian, feministy website, I think we should have at least one post about her. On the other hand, I don’t really have anything to say. It’s another case of: it’s just so awful, what is there to say? (Sorry, sorry, I know it’s bad form to link to yourself…)
To update our non-Canadian readers, (or anyone who doesn’t follow the thrilling and spectacular world of Canadian politics) Belinda Stronach, a.k.a. Liberal MP a.k.a. daughter and C.E.O. of Magna Corp a.k.a. pretty, has been one of the most prominent and controversial characters in politics, in part because she’s done some stunning things in her career: in 2005 she left the Conservative party for the Liberal party. But as far as wild career moves go, that seems to be essentially it. What’s more widely reported is that she’s dated a whole bunch of people, which is weird, considering that the press usually doesn’t report about the private lives of politicians. I can list all of her beaus for the past two years, but I can’t tell you a single thing about what she stands for: she’s boyfriended Peter MacKay, then deputy leader of the Conservative party, Tie Domi, who is a married ex-hockey player who also appears to be a bit of a goon, and apparently Bill Clinton (I’m confused about that one).
Over the past month, in a country famous for being overly polite and just a little afraid of conflict (the war we are fighting in Afghanistan notwithstanding…), three prominent figures have made extremely offensive and lewd comments about her, even to my inured potty mouth ears. Belinda’s love life and the mean things people say about it have gotten more press attention than that time the government fell in 2005 (That’s not an exaggeration!).
1) On Oct 19, Peter MacKay, her ex-bf and our minister of Foreign Affairs, was joking about pollution (a funny subject) in the House of Commons with a Liberal MP. When asked if he was worried about the effects of pollution on his dog, he allegedly pointed to Belinda’s empty chair (she was away that day) and said, “you already have her.” MacKay insists he never said this, despite the fact that several other MPs went on the record as having overheard it. He’s refused to apologise and the Speaker of the House has said that since none of the House recorders picked it up, it can’t be proved definitively that he did say it, and nothing can be done about it.
2) Oct 30: Norman Spector, one time chief of staff and Canadian ambassador, said ON THE RADIO: “You know, I’m not in politics, I can say it, I think [Belinda Stronach]’s a b**** and I think that 90 per cent of men would probably say she’s a b****, for the way she’s broken up [former Maple Leaf] Tie Domi’s home and the way she dumped Peter MacKay. She is a b****.” (I bleeped out b**** not because I’m worried my mum will read this post, but because that word is rife everywhere else, I vote to make this a b****-free space. Unless it’s in reference to Bitch, the magazine.) After, Spector refused to apologise for this remark.
3) And as a grand finale, on Nov 7, Alberta premier Ralph Klein (yup, the leader of one of the most powerful provinces) said in reference to Belinda’s defection to the Liberal party: “‘I wasn’t surprised she crossed over. I don’t think she ever had a Conservative bone in her body — well, except for one,’” said Klein. In case anyone in the audience missed the punch line, he continued: ‘Speaking of Peter MacKay…’” (thanks to my friends at ctv.ca for this quote. And of course, afterwards he refused to apologise.
See, I told you, it’s so horrible, what is there to say about it?
I’m not a Stronach supporter, but I was totally distressed by the comments made about her. It sends a clear message to any young woman bold enough to go into politics in Canada that, if you want to get anywhere, you better date like a nun, keep your mouth shut, and act with more decorum than any man in the house does.
But in the end, what made me want to post about Belinda, was that I heard multiple women complain that, when Belinda responded that MacKay’s comment was “offensive to all women,” she was making the issue about women, when it was only about Belinda. I feel vehemently that that is untrue. As one of the most prominent women in Canada (even if her power is constantly attacked and denigrated), when she’s slurred in public by powerful men in our community, it IS about us.


Digg
six comments
Thea, I am so very glad you posted about this despite the fact that you've been "hemming and hawing." When I learned of Ralph Kline's recent comments and refusal to apologize I was entirely furious. Lately I've been thinking quite a bit on whether or not we live in a "postsexist" world and it is comments like this that prove undoubtedly that we do not. Kline also got on his PR horse and tried to clean up the mess by stating that he was only making a joke about Stronach and not "all women," which is an absurd tactic.
"The fact is that it was a joke," the premier told reporters Thursday.
"I'm making no apologies. I read the copy and I approved it. I thought it was a funny line."
The "she just can't take a joke" comment no longer flies with me, and I've experienced this kind of humour (?) in the workplace likely as much as Stronach has.
Here's the problem- as a culture we believe that we're no longer sexist because we've come so far politically and socially, so this seems to have given people, the media and the politicians the right to make absurd off-colour jokes and claim no responsibility because "hey, c'mon, its 2006, its Canada, there's no way I could be sexist." Yah well, I'm not buying it. I might add here that when Ralph Klein made his "joke" at his roast the entire crowd errupted into laughter but later said they felt "uncomfortable," which says alot more about our "postsexist" society than I'd like to admit.
As for Stronach, I think I have to confess here I am a bit of a fan of hers in many ways. Part of the reason she crossed the floor to the liberals was linked to the gay marriage issue, as she, as a fiscal conservative, could not justify being involved in the imposition of moral judgements on the people of this country. Maybe I am simply a fan of hers because I believe that we need more conservatives who support abortion rights and gun control. I have an immense amount of respect for her because of that and feel it was a bold and rare move to "defect" over principles that deserves accoladates and not school yard mocking.
And as for women thinking "it was only about Belinda," in a "post-sexist" world:
"I don't know of any person who is more respectful of women and who is less inclined to ever tell off-colour jokes or use improper language," Deputy premier Shirley McClellan on Ralph Klein.
Open your eyes, honey. He just did.
Posted by Stacey May
November 12, 2006, 11:55 AM
I read that quote by McClellan and wanted to post but was worried my blog was getting too long...It's amazing the delusions we contort ourselves into in order to believe that we're doing okay...
Thanks for the good info on Stronach, as I admitted I don't really know anything about her platform.
Posted by Thea
November 12, 2006, 3:07 PM
Attacks on Stronach started when she dared to set foot in the political landscape, as if she was too pretty or something to be in politics. Along with the reasons Stacy May outlined, I believe that another reason she crossed the floor was because she knew there would be very few opportunities for advancement in the current Tory party and it didnt look like that could change any time soon. There were barriers to her personally (even though she raised much more money for the party than Harper did) and as a woman.
Personally, I think she is an ambitious and outspoken woman and I support her career.
Posted by Deborah B.
November 13, 2006, 10:42 AM
Hello Thea,
Saw a link to this througha blog that I follow. As always you have insightful commentary. Let me know when your book is available.
Peter Josselyn
Posted by Peter Josselyn
November 14, 2006, 9:07 AM
[...] However you feel about Clinton and her politics, it’s going to be fascinating to watch the way she will be portrayed by the media during the lead up to the big race. Although the international climate for female heads of states is warming up (see Chile’s Michelle Bachelet and Liberia’s Ellen Johnson-Sirleaf, for examples), women in power, especially politics, tend to get a very chilly reception from the press, pundits and even fellow politicians. The recent Belinda Stronach episode shed some fascinating light on the struggles women still face when trying to break into politics. [...]
Posted by Shameless Magazine - for girls who get it » She’s
January 21, 2007, 12:35 AM
Hello Belinda,
I was shocked to read about your cancer this morning.
Fight it!
God bless you!
Posted by Guy Forget
June 23, 2007, 9:25 AM
Leave a comment
This blog post is older than 90 days old. All comments submitted regarding this post will be automatically held for review by the editors before posting. Your comment will not appear on the site until it has been approved.
Our comment policy
Shameless prides itself on the diversity of opinions expressed by our writers, and we encourage and appreciate different points of view. Our intention at Shameless is to foster community and to maintain a safe and positive blogging environment; we do not consider it our duty to give a voice to anybody with an opinion.
Discussion on this site is moderated. We will delete comments that:
(We get to decide what's discriminatory, hateful, attacking, or inflammatory).
In some cases, we will cap off comments on a discussion when we feel they are spiralling out of control and fostering an unwelcoming space for bloggers and readers. Comments will be closed by the Web Editor, unless the post is by the Web Editor, in which case the Editor in Chief will close them.
If your comments repeatedly make the same point, they may be deleted. This also applies to comments made by multiple members of the same organization.
Your comments should be about the topic of the post, not its writer—although we certainly encourage praise for our writers, if you want to say something nice.